The first issue appeared in 1942, published in Washington, U.S.A. Editors for the fanzine included Francis T. Laney, Samuel D. Russell, and Duane Rimel. Rah Hoffman was listed as Art Director. The first two issues were hectographed and the subsequent issues were mimeographed.
Issue One featured the "Map of Arkham", drawn by H.P. Lovecraft. Other issues of The Acolyte included "The Cthulhu Mythology: A Glossary" by Francis T. Laney, essays by Fritz Leiber about Lovecraft's fiction, as well as fiction in the fantasy and supernatural genres, and poetry. Also featured were contributions by Clark Ashton Smith, as well as many previously unpublished essays by Lovecraft.
Later issues list F. Lee Baldwin (The Star Rover), Duane Rimel and Harold Wakefield as contibuting editors.
Other contributors included Virginia Anderson (a.k.a. Hyacinthe Hill), Robert Avrett, Robert Barlow, Stuart Morton Boland, Ruby Diehr, W.R. Gibson, Henry Hasse (Emil Petaja), Arthur F. Hillman, Lilith Lorraine (Challenge), Elmer Perdue, E. Hoffmann Price, Samuel D. Russell, Margaret Stavely, Tigrina (a.k.a. Eydthe Eyde, editor of Vice Versa), Bob Tucker (Le Zombie), Donald Wandrei , Harry Warner, Jr. (Spaceways) and Carol Wyatt.
Art work was contributed by Thomas G. L. Cockroft, Alva Rogers, Harold Wakefield, Carol Wyatt, and Howard Wandrei.
Two works of writing from The Acolyte are considered essential in the creation of the Cthulhu Mythos, including "Music of the Stars" by Duane W. Rimel, and "Horror at Vecra" by Henry Hasse.
Four issues of The Acolyte were published in Washington 1943, and three in 1944. The winter of 1945 saw one issue released, after which the publisher, Francis Laney, moved to Los Angeles, where he released three more issues that year. In 1946 the last two issues were released.